If we ascribe the descriptor of “hero” to Harry Kane what have we left for the FDNY firemen on 9/11 ?

The lazy use of language is everywhere in modern discourse – regular readers will know my hatred of the word “Iconic” which is frequently used , and never correctly. But today I’d like to look at “hero” which, whilst often used correctly, is also all too often used gratuitously and inappropriately.

Sport is perhaps the main culprit. If a footballer is one of our own he becomes a hero – by playing football. That’s it. Period. He doesn’t have to win. Many years ago Stephen Pile published a book that was a salute to the “Not Terribly Good Club of Great Britain” – to the concept of “Heroic Failure”.

But whether heroism is ironically about failure (The Charge of the Light Brigade. The retreat from Dunkirk) or about sporting “heroism” (including the heroic failure of losing a Cup Final) we are in danger of obscuring the true meaning of heroism. Boris Johnson, never a man to miss a chance for populist rhetoric, said after England lost to Italy “This England team deserve to be lauded as heroes.” Well of course he did.

My father was for more than three years a prisoner of the Japanese on the Burma railway. In some people’s eyes that fact alone makes him a “Hero”. I don’t think that, and nor did he. My researches tells me that as a POW my Dad did, actually, do some brave things. He hid part of the Camp radio in his boot for example. This was certainly courageous but “heroic” ? Not really.

The problem is this. There are true acts of heroism from time to time – the sort of things that win a Victoria or George Cross. The workers of the New York Fire Department on 9/11 for example. If we ascribe the descriptor of “hero” to Harry Kane what have we left for the firemen?


One thought on “If we ascribe the descriptor of “hero” to Harry Kane what have we left for the FDNY firemen on 9/11 ?

  1. I could not agree more Paddy, thank you. I am not a follower of football. I struggle to understand the tribal emotion it creates.
    One of my interests in sport is road cycling where truly riders could be described as heroes but not really. They train and work at it to achieve amazing results. That’s not heroism it is just the reward for hard work. Also, cycling does not attract nationalists so few politicians support it and jump on its bandwagon.
    True heroism is when someone risks their own life to save or protect another from harm.
    Attributing that word to football players is arrant nonsense. Johnson seeks to want to bask in some delusional reflected glory. It’s ugly pretentious and unworthy for a prime minister but exactly what I expect.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s