Parris’s intention to vote Conservative is , by his admission, tribal. Disappointingly so.

An uncharacteristically binary pro Conservative view of politics from Matthew Parris in The Times today, which ignores the reality that over his lifetime Britain has been a mixed economy. With one exception that I’ll come on to. That mixed economy was created by the, in retrospect, astonishing achievements of Clement Attlee’s post war government. True that administration had a mild Clause 4 mindset which led to one or two inappropriate nationalisations. But the Welfare State they created has just about remained intact.

The mixed economy, the efficient working of both the public and the private sectors, was largely a British creation though it became ubiquitous across Europe. It is absolutely mutually dependent – public services need private companies to support them and private companies need efficient public services. In short some things are better publicly owned and run and some things demand the competition that private enterprise brings.

The interruption to the continuity of the mixed economy was in the 1980s when an ideologically driven Margaret Thatcher took an axe to public ownership. Some of her actions were necessary but grotesquely insensitively handled (the mines obviously). Some were scandalously corrupt – the railways and water for example – culpable errors from which we are still suffering.

Rishi Sunak, who Parris’s Conservative vote will help, is by his own admission an unreformed Thatcherite. Others around him are not supporters of the mixed economy at all. Does he really want these Tufton Street terrors to stay?

One thought on “Parris’s intention to vote Conservative is , by his admission, tribal. Disappointingly so.

  1. Parris writes about “a good opposition” suggesting only the Tories can be one. Starmer and his party have been pretty good in opposition in the last few years and Corbyn too. I know you are ambivalent towards Corbyn but he did try to bring decency back to parliament. He was fighting a losing battle. The ranks in the army of the ERG and their far-right views on absolutely everything ground his aspirations into dust.

    As for Parrish once a Tory always a selfish free market in all things and at at any cost Thatcherite. The ghost of ‘the blessed St Margaret’ will haunt the Tories and half the country until doomsday.

    I wonder what she would make of Reform?

    Like

Leave a comment